In Brazil, Meta suspended over free use of press content for AI
Brazilian courts have banned Meta from using press content for free to train its AI. The provisional injunction targets new usage conditions imposed on companies and may still evolve.
Brazilian courts suspended on Tuesday the obligation for media to provide their content free of charge to Meta for training its artificial intelligence. The provisional injunction targets the parent company of Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp, responding to requests from several press associations. At stake is a classic but consequential dispute: who pays for the data that feeds AI?
An injunction blocking Meta’s new conditions
Judge Guilherme Madeira Dezem prohibited Meta from collecting content from media linked to three press associations without prior hearing the company. The decision does not definitively settle the case but suspends part of the new usage conditions intended for companies, which were to take effect on November 20. According to the judge, the damages would be "irreversible" once AI is trained with this content.
In his ruling, he wrote: "Imposing on media the free and universal availability of their creative heritage as a toll to remain connected to the channels where contemporary audiences consume information constitutes a manifest abuse of rights." Meta therefore cannot sanction media refusing these conditions, at least until a final decision.
Why the press industry sees a precedent
National associations of newspapers, magazines, radio, and TV denounce an obligation they consider asymmetrical: accepting to give content to continue using Meta’s platforms. They believe this decision is the first worldwide to support a coalition of media opposing such conditions [to be verified]. For them, the signal goes beyond the Brazilian case, as it concerns publishers’ ability to retain control over their editorial heritage in the era of generative model training.
Marcelo Rech, executive president of the National Association of Newspapers (ANJ), hailed "a very positive signal showing that there are limits to economic power abuse." The phrase targets both Meta and the power balance between large platforms and publishers. And, for once, the algorithm did not have the last word.
What Meta faces now
The company has five days after notification to present its defense. If it fails to comply with the ban, it faces a daily fine of one million reais, about 162,000 euros at the rate indicated in the source. At this stage, Meta has not immediately responded to AFP requests.
A fundamental question remains: if the decision is confirmed, it could strengthen the position of media seeking to charge for the use of their content by AI systems, instead of letting it enter by default in usage conditions. The Brazilian case thus goes beyond the legal field. It also tests how platforms will reckon, or not, with publishers in their next training phase.
Key points
- Provisional decision issued Tuesday in Brazil.
- Meta targeted for its business usage conditions.
- Possible fine: one million reais per day.
- Marcelo Rech calls it a "very positive signal."
- Effective date planned for November 20.
By the numbers
- 3 press associations — newspapers, magazines, radio and TV, Brazil, AFP source.
- November 20 — planned effective date of new conditions, AFP source.
- 1 million reais per day — potential fine for non-compliance, about 162,000 euros, AFP source.
- 5 days — deadline given to Meta to present its defense after notification, AFP source.